In the story "Superman and Me" it talks about how a "smart indian" can be dangerous. Indians are often stereotyped as the people who don't know anything and can't become anything strictly because they are Indian. As the story goes on to say, a "smart indian" can be dangerous for a couple of reasons. They are ridiculed and feared by others or non-indians. Some may think that they won't amount to anything in life because of the stereotypes of the indian culture, which is why Alexie says that he saved his own life and wants to save the lives of other Indians, talking about reading and writing specifically in this story.
Indians are expected to do very little because of the background and knowledge we assume to have towards them. Indian children in schools were expeced to fail outside of the "Indian world." They would stay quiet and sit in the back of the classroom. They grew up with the tradition of not learning to read or write which I could see how it would effect them in a lot of ways during their education. Unlike Alexie who taught himself to read and write because of his fathers interest in books and reading and things like that. I think what he means by smart indians being dangerous maybe to their peers and society as well, is the fact if Indians ignored the stereotype of their culture and applied themselves to do what they believe they can do, then it would be sort of like a "threat" to the non indians, proving that they can amount to what they set themselves up for. Anyone can do anything they really put forth the effort into, it's just a matter of how bad you want what your aiming for. In the story, Alexie is obviously the perfect example of someone who didn't give up and didn't give in to the negative aspects of the indian background and culture. He refused to fail. He was arrogant, and lucky and smart. And he did everything he could to acheive what he has today. He put forth the effort and did what he had to do for himself. He saved his life by not being affected by the "non-indians" and the things they had to say and portray for so many years. And the same goes for those he inteds to help with their lives as well. An indian who had experience with a negative atmosphere but still managed to "save his own life" growing up and knowing that reading and writing is the overall foundation from a decent to a very well education.
Hi Hailey,
ReplyDeleteThe power of this reading is the way it confronts the self-fulfilling prophecy of stereotypes, specifically the ones facing Native American children. Children learn to see themselves first through the eyes of those who love them, and then through the individuals they encounter. In school, teachers and students "teach" each other how to perceive and define others.
If the dominant thinking is that an entire group of people is inherently unteachable, then people will begin to act and treat each other accordingly. Just believing the stereotype has the power to make it become the truth.
In this story, it took just one person willing to be a social outcast to defy the stereotype, prove it wrong and then challenge others to follow his lead.
Thanks for giving me more to think about.
Take care,
Lauren
Hailey,
ReplyDeleteThis type of stereotypical thinking still occurs now. This is very saddening because if we think about it, we've advanced in so many fields like science, math, technology, but we lack something very important. We still categorize people based on their ethnic background or their financial background. In Alexie's case, he was ridiculed because he was supposed to be like his Indian peers. He was supposed to do poorly in school. He didn't let these predetermined notions about how he was supposed to turn out get him down.
In a similar way, those that have to personally deal with racism and stereotyping, need to ignore those external ideas. We're all very smart even if sometimes we don't completely use our brain to the best of it's ability. We're capable of accomplishing anything we want. It's a matter of having the will and the determination to succeed. Alexie is a perfect example of this. He's an admirable man and we should all strive to be a little more like him.
You're completely right about the fact that how much effort you put towards your work is what you're going to get back. Most people today have life way to easy and dont have to fight for what they want and that is why the "Indians" and third world countries are kicking our butts in the united states because they know what it takes to survive in this world. If we had the motivations and drive like these people who suffer everyday it would be a completely different world.
ReplyDeleteJust like you i feel they are harassed or ridiculed for being smart just because they are Indian but i feel liken they are just like any other person in this world if they put their mind to it they can excel in anything
ReplyDeleteYou brought a really good point about how Native American culture is different than that of American culture. While reading the excerpt I didn't think about how culture could affect a Native American's learning in/by a Non-Native American teacher and school. Lots of Native American history that I know of is passed down from generation to generation by word of mouth and not by written text. This could affect how a Native American learns in a classroom compared a student use to a teacher talk and taking notes.
ReplyDelete